Survey

In spite of high inflation some cost savings were obtained. How much net cost changes in the last 6-12 months did you obtain over or under the budget?

More than 10% under.
1 to 10% under.
No change.
1% to 5% over,
6% or more over.

Good buyers are proud of their ability to negotiate, and well they should be. The ability to negotiate w..." />

Never Assume You Have the Lowest Cost

Date: 06/01/2010

Good buyers are proud of their ability to negotiate, and well they should be. The ability to negotiate well is a valuable skill honed by education and experience. But the danger lies in assuming you have achieved the lowest possible obtainable cost. In most cases this is not true.

Let’s not confuse cost with price. There may be a lower price out there somewhere, but there may not. Cost is another matter. It can be hard for novices to understand, but it may be necessary to pay a higher price in order to obtain a lower cost.

The cost not only includes the price paid for the product but includes also the labor to use the product as well as the durability of the product. For example, you may need to pay ten or twenty or more percentage higher in price to have a better product that lasts twice as long.

You may need to pay a much higher price to reduce the amount of labor necessary to use the product. The smart buyer must calculate the advantages of paying more in the short run with the cost in the long run. The probable need for the product over time must be compared with any potential savings.

Well informed buyers know that suppliers argue that their higher price is justified because labor savings and long-run cost more than justify their higher prices. They point to better quality and better service to encourage purchase of their product rather than the competition’s. Their arguments can be true and sometimes are, but it is naive to assume they are. The buyer must take the time and effort to do his or her own calculations. The seller rarely knows the buyer’s long-term needs and therefore can’t objectively evaluate the total cost of the purchase.

Buyers frequently encounter a problem when paying a higher price for a product that is justified by a long-run lower cost. Non-purchasing personnel, including managers and executives, may only learn of the amount paid versus a lower price in the marketplace. They then become overly concerned about the performance of their purchasing operation. It is necessary that buyers record the reasons and justification for a higher price paid and educate non-purchasing personnel about the difference between price and cost.